In a world overflowing with productivity apps, time management courses, and endless lists of things to do, we often find ourselves caught in a whirlwind of busyness—doing a lot, but achieving little in terms of meaning and fulfillment. Jay Payleitner’s thought-provoking book, What If God Wrote Your To Do List?: 52 Ways to Make the Most of Every Day, offers a refreshing and spiritually grounded alternative. More than just another self-help or devotional book, this work invites readers on a transformative journey—one that redefines productivity not by how much we accomplish, but by how deeply we connect with God, others, and our own purpose.
With 52 concise, insightful chapters—each designed as a weekly reflection—Payleitner masterfully blends humor, practical wisdom, and biblical truth to challenge readers to rethink their daily priorities. In this comprehensive review and summary, we’ll explore the core themes of the book, unpack its key messages, and reflect on the powerful spiritual and emotional impact it can have on individuals seeking a more intentional, grace-filled life.
Overview: A Fresh Take on Purpose and Productivity
What If God Wrote Your To Do List? is not about efficiency hacks or cramming more tasks into your day. Instead, it flips the script on traditional productivity culture by asking a simple yet profound question: What if the Almighty Himself were to write your daily agenda? This imaginative premise sets the tone for a book that is both playful and deeply spiritual.
Jay Payleitner, an accomplished author, speaker, and radio host, brings his signature blend of wit and warmth to this devotional-style guide. Known for his ability to make faith accessible and relatable, Payleitner avoids preachy tones and instead uses everyday scenarios—traffic jams, family dinners, work stress, and quiet moments—to illustrate how God’s priorities might differ from our own.
The book is structured as 52 weekly reflections, making it ideal for year-long reading. Each chapter is short (typically 3–5 pages), easy to digest, and ends with a “To-Do” suggestion and a reflective question. This format makes it perfect for morning devotionals, small group discussions, or evening reflections.
Themes and Takeaways
While we won’t cover all 52 chapters in full detail, let’s explore the major themes and highlight several representative chapters to illustrate the depth and diversity of Payleitner’s insights.
“Call That Person You’ve Been Meaning To” (Week 1)
One of the earliest chapters sets the tone for the entire book: relationships matter more than tasks. Payleitner shares a personal story about finally calling an old friend after months of “I’ll do it later.” The conversation ends up being deeply meaningful—reconnecting, healing old wounds, and reminding both men of their shared history.
Key Message: God values connection over completion. A simple phone call can be more significant than checking off ten items on your list.
To-Do Suggestion: Call someone today—not because you need something, but just to say hello.
This chapter introduces a recurring theme: intentionality. In a digital age where we text instead of talk and “like” instead of love, Payleitner challenges readers to invest in real, human connection.
“Forgive That Person You’ve Been Avoiding” (Week 4)
Here, Payleitner tackles one of the heaviest burdens we carry—unresolved conflict. He doesn’t offer a quick fix but instead invites readers to consider the emotional and spiritual cost of holding grudges.
Using the parable of the unforgiving servant (Matthew 18:21–35), he reminds us that we’ve been forgiven much—and therefore, we are called to forgive others, even when it’s hard.
Key Message: Forgiveness isn’t about excusing bad behavior; it’s about freeing yourself from bitterness.
To-Do Suggestion: Identify one person you need to forgive. Write them a letter (you don’t have to send it), expressing your willingness to let go.
This chapter stands out for its emotional honesty. Payleitner doesn’t minimize pain but emphasizes that forgiveness is a gift we give ourselves.
“Say ‘Thank You’ Like You Mean It” (Week 7)
Gratitude is a common theme in Christian living, but Payleitner gives it a fresh twist. He encourages readers to move beyond generic “thanks” and express gratitude in specific, heartfelt ways.
He shares a story about thanking a waitress not just with a tip, but with a note that acknowledged her hard work and kindness. The impact? She cried.
Key Message: Gratitude, when sincere and specific, becomes a spiritual act of worship.
To-Do Suggestion: Thank someone today in a way they won’t expect—by naming exactly what you appreciate about them.
This chapter reinforces the idea that small, intentional acts can carry divine significance.
“Let Someone Else Go First” (Week 10)
In a culture obsessed with speed and self-advancement, humility is countercultural. Payleitner uses the image of letting someone merge in traffic or stepping back in line as a metaphor for Christ-like humility.
He references Philippians 2:3–4: “Do nothing out of selfish ambition or vain conceit. Rather, in humility value others above yourselves.”
Key Message: True greatness is found in service, not status.
To-Do Suggestion: Look for one opportunity today to let someone go ahead of you—literally or figuratively.
This chapter is a gentle nudge toward selflessness, reminding readers that love often looks like inconvenience.
“Stop Complaining for a Day” (Week 13)
One of the most impactful chapters, this one challenges the pervasive habit of grumbling. Payleitner admits he’s guilty of it too—complaining about the weather, slow internet, or long lines.
But he asks: What if a day without complaint became a spiritual discipline? He cites James 5:9: “Don’t grumble against one another, brothers and sisters, or you will be judged.”
Key Message: Complaints steal joy and distance us from gratitude. Silence can be a form of worship.
To-Do Suggestion: Go one full day without complaining. Keep a mental or written log.
Many readers report this being a game-changer—revealing just how much negativity they carry unconsciously.
“Spend 15 Minutes in Silence” (Week 16)
In our hyper-connected world, silence is rare—and often uncomfortable. Payleitner encourages readers to sit in stillness, not to meditate in a generic sense, but to listen for God.
He shares how he started doing this during his morning coffee, turning off the radio and phone, and simply being present.
Key Message: God often speaks in whispers. Silence creates space for His voice.
To-Do Suggestion: Find a quiet place and sit in silence for 15 minutes. No phone, no music, no agenda.
This chapter is a powerful antidote to spiritual burnout and noise overload.
“Tell Someone You’re Proud of Them” (Week 19)
Praise is often underused. Payleitner challenges readers to celebrate others—not just for big achievements, but for everyday faithfulness.
He tells the story of telling his teenage son, “I’m proud of the man you’re becoming,” which led to an emotional hug and deeper connection.
Key Message: Encouragement builds people up. It reflects God’s affirming love.
To-Do Suggestion: Tell someone—your spouse, child, coworker, friend—that you’re proud of them. Be specific.
This chapter highlights the transformative power of affirmation.
“Do a Good Deed in Secret” (Week 22)
Inspired by Jesus’ teaching in Matthew 6:3–4 (“do not let your left hand know what your right hand is doing”), this chapter celebrates anonymous kindness.
Payleitner suggests paying for the coffee of the person behind you in line or shoveling a neighbor’s driveway without telling them.
Key Message: True generosity seeks no recognition. It’s done for God’s eyes only.
To-Do Suggestion: Perform a kind act today that no one will know about.
This chapter fosters a heart of humility and service.
“Read a Real Book (Not on a Screen)” (Week 25)
In a digital age, Payleitner makes a case for the spiritual and mental benefits of physical books. He argues that reading an actual book—especially Scripture or a devotional—creates a slower, more reflective experience.
Key Message: Slowing down our consumption of information helps us absorb truth more deeply.
To-Do Suggestion: Read 10 pages of a physical book today—preferably something uplifting or spiritual.
This chapter is a quiet protest against digital overload.
“Pray for Someone You Dislike” (Week 28)
One of the most challenging chapters, this one calls for radical love. Payleitner doesn’t ask readers to become best friends with their enemies, but simply to pray for them.
He shares how praying for a difficult coworker changed his heart over time.
Key Message: Prayer transforms the pray-er as much as the prayed-for.
To-Do Suggestion: Name someone you struggle with and pray a simple blessing over them.
This chapter embodies Jesus’ command to “love your enemies” (Matthew 5:44).
Recurring Themes and Spiritual Insights
As we move through the 52 weeks, several key themes emerge that form the backbone of Payleitner’s message:
Redefining Productivity
The central idea of the book is that true productivity isn’t measured by output, but by impact. God’s to do list would include things like “comfort the grieving,” “encourage the discouraged,” and “reconcile the broken”—not “reply to 50 emails” or “finish the report.”
Payleitner gently critiques our cultural obsession with busyness, reminding readers that being busy doesn’t mean you’re being faithful.
The Sacredness of Small Things
One of the most beautiful aspects of the book is its celebration of the ordinary. A kind word, a shared meal, a moment of silence—these are not trivial. In God’s economy, they are sacred.
Payleitner shows how spiritual growth often happens in the “in-between” moments—the drive to work, the coffee break, the bedtime routine.
Intentionality Over Habit
Many of us live on autopilot. Payleitner calls for intentional living—making conscious choices to love, serve, and connect. Each “To-Do” suggestion is designed to break routine and awaken spiritual awareness.
Grace Over Guilt
Unlike some devotional books that leave readers feeling inadequate, Payleitner writes with grace. He shares his own failures—forgetting to call, snapping at his kids, giving in to impatience. This vulnerability makes the book relatable and non-judgmental.
His tone is never “You should,” but “What if you tried?”
Relationship-Centered Faith
At its core, this book is about relationships—with God, with others, and with ourselves. Every suggestion points toward connection: calling, forgiving, thanking, listening.
Payleitner reminds us that faith isn’t just about beliefs; it’s about behavior. And behavior is shaped by love.
What Message Does the Author Want to Convey?
Jay Payleitner’s ultimate message is both simple and profound: God’s priorities are different from ours—and when we align with His, our lives become more meaningful, peaceful, and joyful.
He wants readers to understand that:
- God values people over projects. A delayed task is less important than a heartfelt conversation.
- Love is the highest calling. Everything Jesus taught and modeled points to love—of God and neighbor.
- Spiritual growth happens in daily choices. Holiness isn’t achieved in grand gestures, but in consistent, small acts of kindness, patience, and faith.
- We are not defined by our busyness. Our worth comes from being beloved children of God, not from how much we accomplish.
In essence, Payleitner is inviting readers to live differently—not by doing more, but by doing what matters. He’s not against productivity; he’s for purposeful productivity.
Who Should Read This Book?
What If God Wrote Your To Do List? is ideal for:
- Christians seeking a deeper, more practical faith – It bridges the gap between theology and daily life.
- Overwhelmed professionals and parents – Offers a counter-cultural rhythm of rest, connection, and grace.
- Small group or church study groups – The weekly format and discussion questions make it perfect for group use.
- Skeptics or spiritual seekers – The tone is warm and inclusive, not dogmatic.
- Anyone feeling spiritually dry or stuck – The book reignites wonder and intentionality.
It’s especially valuable for those who feel they’re “doing all the right things” but still feel disconnected from God or others.
Strengths of the Book
- Accessible Writing Style – Payleitner writes like a friend chatting over coffee—warm, funny, and honest.
- Practical Application – Each chapter ends with a clear, doable action step.
- Biblical Foundation – While not a verse-by-verse study, the book is deeply rooted in Scripture.
- Emotional Resonance – Stories about family, failure, and forgiveness make it deeply relatable.
- Flexible Format – Can be read in any order, making it user-friendly for busy readers.
Potential Criticisms (and Responses)
Some readers might find:
- The chapters too short – While brief, their brevity is intentional, making them digestible for busy lives.
- Lack of deep theological exploration – This isn’t a theology textbook; it’s a devotional guide focused on practice.
- Repetition of themes – Forgiveness, gratitude, and kindness recur, but this reinforces core spiritual habits.
These aren’t flaws, but features of the book’s design. It’s meant to be a gentle, consistent nudge—not a heavy academic lift.
Final Thoughts: A Book for Our Time
In an age of distraction, anxiety, and endless scrolling, What If God Wrote Your To Do List? is a timely and timeless gift. Jay Payleitner doesn’t offer a 7-step program or a magic formula. Instead, he offers something far more valuable: a vision for a life that matters.
He reminds us that God isn’t interested in our efficiency. He’s interested in our hearts.
Each chapter is a gentle invitation—to slow down, to love well, to listen closely, and to live with purpose. And when we imagine God writing our to do list, we begin to see that the most important tasks aren’t the ones we cross off—but the ones that leave a lasting imprint on the soul.
Conclusion: Let God Redefine Your Day
What If God Wrote Your To Do List? by Jay Payleitner is more than just a book—it’s a guide to living a purposeful, faith-centered life. It challenges the myth that busyness equals success and replaces it with a truer measure: love in action.
By imagining God’s priorities for our days, we begin to see that the smallest acts—calling a friend, forgiving a hurt, sitting in silence—can be the most sacred.
If you’re tired of feeling overwhelmed, disconnected, or spiritually dry, this book offers a gentle, grace-filled path forward. It won’t add more to your plate. Instead, it will help you savor what’s already there.
So, what would be on your divine to do list?
Perhaps it starts with reading this book—one week at a time.
FAQs
Q1 Is this book only for Christians?
Not at all. While it is rooted in Christian faith, its core lessons—gratitude, forgiveness, love, and purpose—are universal.
Q2 Can I read one chapter a day instead of weekly?
Yes, you can. But the weekly approach allows for deeper reflection and practice.
Q How practical are the lessons?
Very practical. Each lesson is simple and can be applied in daily life, regardless of your schedule.
Q4 Is it suitable as a gift?
Absolutely. It makes a thoughtful gift for friends, family, or anyone looking for encouragement.
Q5 Does it require deep theological knowledge?
No, the book is written in plain language, making it accessible to everyone.